World Court to Issue Landmark Genocide Ruling on Myanmar

World Court to Issue Landmark Genocide Ruling on Myanmar

Judges at The Hague weigh state accountability under the 1948 Genocide Convention

The International Court of Justice is preparing to answer a question no court has ever formally resolved: whether a state can be held directly responsible for genocide. The judgment, expected Thursday at The Hague, will address allegations that Myanmar violated the 1948 UN Genocide Convention in its treatment of the Rohingya Muslim minority. It arrives as the legal threshold for genocide is being tested in a second, closely watched case before the same court, brought by South Africa against the Israeli regime over its war on Gaza.

The Gambia, a Muslim-majority country, initiated the case against Myanmar, arguing that systematic repression and military operations against the Rohingya constituted genocide. The proceedings follow a military campaign nearly a decade ago that forced hundreds of thousands of Rohingya to flee across the border into Bangladesh. As reported in coverage carried at https://www.tasnimnews.ir/en/news/2026/11/15/3749085/icj-to-rule-on-myanmar-genocide-allegations-in-landmark-case-with-implications-for-israel, the ruling is expected to shape how the court approaches the question of genocidal intent in other proceedings, including the Gaza case.

For the court itself, the decision marks a critical moment in international law. The world’s highest court has never directly found a state responsible for genocide, a crime defined in the aftermath of the Nazi-led Holocaust. The ICJ has previously considered mass atrocities in the Balkans, but those proceedings stopped short of finding states directly responsible; Serbia was found legally responsible only for failing to prevent the genocide at Srebrenica. Both the Myanmar and Gaza cases concern allegations of a powerful military targeting an ethnic or national group, leaving judges to determine how evidence of systematic violence, mass killings and the destruction of civilian communities establishes genocidal intent.

Proving that specific intent has been the central issue in the Myanmar proceedings. The Convention defines genocide as acts committed with the intention of destroying, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. Antonia Mulvey, founder of Legal Action Worldwide, an organization representing hundreds of Rohingya survivors, said she was “cautiously optimistic” that the court would hold Myanmar fully accountable, arguing that patterns of government conduct demonstrated clear attempts to destroy the community. “The attacks on the villages took place the same way,” she said, describing how civilians were attacked, villages burned, men and women separated, sexual violence committed, and fleeing victims killed. She emphasized the role of rape and sexual violence in establishing intent, citing testimonies describing soldiers mutilating women’s genitals and biting their faces. “That’s to mark people, to brand them … it is also to stop reproduction,” she said, adding that such violence is “a critical part to show their intent to destroy the group.”

The court heard directly from survivors in January, during closed-door sessions with Rohingya who travelled from refugee camps in Bangladesh. According to Legal Action Worldwide, one witness described her child being taken from her arms, stabbed and thrown into a fire, while another recounted seeing piles of bodies in a mass grave. Gambian Justice Minister Dawda Jallow told the court that the proceedings concerned the fate of an entire population rather than abstract legal questions. “This is not about esoteric issues of international law,” he said. “It is about real people, real stories and a real group of human beings. The Rohingya of Myanmar. They have been targeted for destruction.”

The allegations rest on decades of persecution, discrimination and denial of citizenship in Myanmar’s western Rakhine state. The crisis escalated in 2017 after a Rohingya militant group launched guerrilla-style attacks, prompting what the military called “clearance operations.” Survivors told the Guardian of a massacre in the village of Tula Toli, and satellite imagery later confirmed the village had been razed. A finding against Myanmar would increase pressure on Min Aung Hlaing, who led the military during the 2016-2017 attacks and seized power in a 2021 coup that overthrew the elected government of Aung San Suu Kyi, triggering a civil war that has killed tens of thousands. He is separately under investigation by the International Criminal Court, which prosecutes individuals, over alleged crimes against humanity, and was installed as civilian president in April following elections widely condemned as a sham.

Meanwhile, the ruling unfolds amid growing tension between Washington and international judicial institutions. Although the Biden administration formally recognized the Rohingya atrocities as genocide, Trump’s UN ambassador, Mike Waltz, warned that the ICJ “must not be allowed” to establish a genocide standard applicable to “allied soldiers,” a warning with particular significance for Israeli military personnel given the Gaza proceedings. The United States has imposed sanctions on the ICC, raising questions about how political alliances influence enforcement of accountability. The ICJ lacks its own enforcement mechanism, and divisions among major powers, particularly the United States and China, could block Security Council measures, though its judgments carry considerable legal and political weight.

More than 1 million Rohingya refugees remain in Bangladesh, in the world’s largest refugee settlement, while fewer than 600,000 are estimated to remain inside Myanmar. Yanghee Lee, a former UN rights investigator on Myanmar, called the ruling a historic opportunity, saying the international community failed to prevent the atrocities nine years ago and must now “finally secure justice for the Rohingya.” A displaced Rohingya told the Guardian he hoped the judgment would “help end decades of persecution and discrimination,” adding, “We are asking for justice, recognition, equal rights and a future in which our children can live safely and with dignity in their own homeland.”

Whether the court’s first-ever finding of state responsibility for genocide will translate into enforcement, given the Security Council’s divisions, remains the open question hanging over Thursday’s judgment.

Q&A

Who brought the case against Myanmar and on what legal basis?

The Gambia, a Muslim-majority country, initiated the case at the International Court of Justice, arguing that Myanmar violated the 1948 UN Genocide Convention through systematic repression and military operations against the Rohingya Muslim minority.

Why is this ruling considered a landmark for international law?

The ICJ has never directly found a state responsible for genocide. In earlier Balkans proceedings, Serbia was found legally responsible only for failing to prevent the genocide at Srebrenica, so Thursday's judgment could be the first direct finding of state responsibility for genocide.

What has been the central legal issue in the Myanmar proceedings?

Proving specific genocidal intent. The Convention defines genocide as acts committed with the intention of destroying, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, and judges must determine how evidence of systematic violence, mass killings and destruction of civilian communities establishes that intent.

What obstacles could prevent the ruling from being enforced?

The ICJ lacks its own enforcement mechanism, and divisions among major powers, particularly the United States and China, could block Security Council measures, though its judgments carry considerable legal and political weight.